An Open Letter to Animal Rights Advocates

To All the Animals Rights Advocates in the World,

I often hear people dismiss animal advocates as radical or fanatic. In some circles, the term has a negative connotation like “hippie” or “emo.” Fortunately, as people learn the truth about animal agriculture, the fur trade, seaquariums, the circus, experiments on animals, and other acts of cruelty, the perception changes. As advocates, it’s important for us to communicate our message in a way that aspiring advocates find welcoming and plausible. That is our challenge. As with any movement, before the sensibility of it has been fully realized, resistance abounds.

Where does some of the rage and impatience originate in animal rights advocates? It’s largely rooted in the fact that the reasons for which we changed are problems that can be solved. As soon as people decide make simple changes in their lives, they can transition from someone who contributes to land degradation, water and air pollution, a loss of biodiversity, world hunger, and the confinement, abuse and slaughter of animals to someone who no longer supports these acts of cruelty. We don’t need any scientists in labs to solve this disease of the human heart.

Understandably, sometimes advocates’ frustration gets the better of them when people offer trite replies such as “I could never give up chicken” after watching a video or reading a book about the horrors of factory farming even though companies make delicious plant-based alternatives. An animal advocate has likely seen a chicken inhumanely confined, diseased, debeaked, scalded, skinned, and shredded alive so when the animal eater’s response and the imagery collide, it may ignite a visceral reaction that causes anger to trump reason. To care so much is a fault worth little criticism although it is prudent to stay focused on the goal which must always be the animals’ best interests.

When people say they’re volunteering to end child abuse, poverty, crime, cancer, or working to improve other social conditions, their fellow citizens typically embrace, admire, and celebrate their efforts even if they don’t join them. It’s rare that they’re ever called overzealous no matter how significant their involvement.

Why is it that animal advocates are so often harshly criticized, mocked, and ostracized? Where does the backlash originate? People who support cruelty to animals sometimes use the criticism as a defense mechanism to justify their complacency because unlike the other aforementioned issues such as child abuse where people are unlikely the cause of the problem, they realize that when it comes to the issues animal advocates work to improve, people who consume animals play a pivotal role. Advocates’ words strike a chord and people who eat, wear, or pay to see animals exploited don’t like it. They understand the meaning of a carbon footprint or the unwatchable death of an animal and they don’t want to confront the reality that they are part of the problem so they seek to sully the credibility of the messengers.

Time and time again, people who make the transition tell us with heavy hearts, “I don’t know what I was thinking. I will never eat animals again. I don’t know if I can ever forgive myself.” We know exactly how they feel.

How do we overcome the dilemma of those who refuse to change? We must recognize people’s motives and remain patient and persistent and continue to inform ourselves and others about the realities of animal agriculture and its impact on animals, people, and the planet and all other forms of cruelty. I’m an abolitionist but I’m also a realist. While ending animal agriculture and allowing animals to live their lives unfettered by the human hand is our goal, we must not dismiss incremental success (i.e. Meatless Monday, vegetarians, people who refuse to wear fur or go to the circus, etc.) if the only other choice is no progress at all. It’s a hard reality to accept in the face of brutality on such a massive scale. It is, however, reality and to deny the scope of the problem and the effort it will take to eradicate it in its entirety or the important impact of every act of kindness is to lack vision about what these decisions mean to the affected animals and what it requires to reach the end goal.

We must carry ourselves with dignity and recognize that our detractors will work hard to find fault with us in order to paint us as fanatics. We must not give them the opportunity. We must work smart and hard. We must stick together. There is too much infighting in the movement that doesn’t serve the best interests of animals. We must be willing to ask ourselves tough questions such as “Is what I’m doing positively impacting animals?” We must hold ourselves to high standards even in the face of conduct unbecoming and be willing to endure ridicule and abuse knowing that the animals suffer a much worse fate than hurtful words.

You will be called crazy and extreme. You are not. They will say you are naive and foolhardy. You are not. They will tell you to get a life. Few people live a more meaningful one. You are heroes for a cause as important as any in the history of the world — the systematic and needless confinement, torture, and slaughter of billions of animals, the destruction of our environment causing global climate change, millions of people dying from human health conditions caused by eating animals and the effects of industrial farming, and millions more dying of starvation because grain that could save them is wasted on animals. You are fighting against enormous odds, including a foe in the powerful agricultural industry that will spare no expense to continue duping the public into believing a web of lies about the realities of eating animals and the nature of agribusiness. Recent efforts by agribusiness to make it illegal to film animal abuse in their factories provide ample evidence that you are making progress.

When the thought of the suffering becomes too much to bear, know that your passion offers hope, your activism has changed and saved lives, and you are not alone. Keep holding those signs, keep handing out leaflets, keep sharing those videos, keep boycotting, keep talking to your friends and family, keep signing petitions, keep calling your legislators, keep educating yourself, keep holding fundraisers, keep supporting animal sanctuaries and other non-profit animal rescue organizations, and keep making the world a more humane place. Don’t stop. Don’t ever stop. You’re making a difference. The world is changing. You’re changing it.

Where there are people advocating for animals, there is compassion, hope, an evolved mind, and a conscience at peace. This is who you are, it is who you will always be, and I will die singing your praises for gracing this earth. History will never forget you. We will get there. As Nelson Mandela said, “It always seems impossible until it’s done.” When its done, future generations will thank you.

Andrew Kirschner, Ed.D., is the founder and CEO of Animal Rescue Bar, a delicious plant-based snack for health-conscious people that donates 50% of its proceeds to non-profit animal rescue and advocacy organizations. To subscribe to this blog and receive new articles via e-mail, enter your e-mail address in the “Follow Blog by E-Mail” link at the top right of the page.

This entry was posted in Letters, Vegans and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

56 Responses to An Open Letter to Animal Rights Advocates

  1. Rebecca says:

    That. Was. Beautiful. Thank you!

  2. Robin G says:

    Thank you Andrew for your eloquence (as always). I need to print this and keep with me for balance, for inspiration..

  3. Sherry Vegan-Blythe says:

    I needed to read this…thank you for putting into words what we all have felt. Although I’m taking a break from the constant assault of horror and ignorance on Facebook, I WILL be back and in the meantime will continue with all my other activities and efforts to spread awareness and compassion! Lots of love to you Andrew…you are family <3

    • Andrew Kirschner says:

      Thank you Sherry. The feeling is mutual. I hope it provided you some comfort and reminded you that you are a hero for animals and compassionate people all over the world. Take care of yourself my friend.

  4. Daniela says:

    Thank you so much Andrew! It gave me so much hope and happiness. I may print it as well and read it when I feel down! :)

  5. Eva Kaveri says:

    THank you Andrew, I am feeling very depressed lately being constantly called crazy and extremist. It seems like I am hitting the wall all the time…Being vegan is a great challange. Your letter makes me feel that I am not alone with my thinking and doing. Light and Peace to you.

  6. Micah says:

    Wow, this made me feel very emotional. Thank you so much for writing this. I will also refer back to this in times of conflict. Thank you.

  7. foreveraloser says:

    Yey!!!

  8. Emily says:

    Thank you for putting into gentle, powerful, encouraging and hopeful words what I believe we all feel and think, but didn’t have the eloquence to share, or perhaps the courage. I’m going to save this letter and re-read it every time I wonder if I’m doing enough. Thank you.

    • Andrew Kirschner says:

      Thank you so much Emily. I’m very grateful to learn that it has served to remind you of your importance in this cause.

  9. Victoria says:

    Thank you Andrew, this is such an important message! I must say that there are times that tears and sorrow almost get the best of me, but then I come back with a smile because I know that only smiles will continue to help our animal family as well as humanity. Thank you again!

    • Andrew Kirschner says:

      Thank you Victoria. I know how you feel. I am proud of you and forever grateful for everything you do for the cause.

  10. keepwhaleswild says:

    Brilliantly written, as long as there is breath in my body I will never stop fighting for what is right, it’s nice to know there are so many people out there that feel the same. If I had just one wish it would be that the whole of humanity would wake up one day and have the same compassion and empathy for all living souls as I do.

  11. Kaleigh says:

    Amen! Very well said.

  12. Carolyn Schwalbe says:

    Thank you,Doctor…sometimes it gets really depressing thinking about all those people who refuse to change their carnivorous ways!!

  13. Reading this provided me with more self-care than i have provided for myself in months. Thank you Andrew.

  14. Richard says:

    I needed to hear that, thank you Andrew.

  15. Gita Devi says:

    Andrew – this was so beautifully written. It speaks from your heart to the heart of all of us. Thank you.

  16. Amanda Mitchell says:

    For all the days when the struggle seems too much. For all the moments when the pain and depression overwhelms. For all the times when the smallness of my actions seems negligible in the face of the suffering. I thank you, Andrew. This is possibly the most powerful gift of writing I have ever received.

    • Hi Amanda,

      Your actions are never small. They all add up and they all matter. Everything you do and say matters. Keep using your voice.

      Thank you for your comments. It brings me great joy to know that my letter reminded you of your importance to the world.

  17. Angela Perez says:

    Thank you very much Andrew. Your words are very significant for me, I think we need people like you to keep our strenghts alive with such eloquent and inspiring speeches :)

  18. Pingback: Why it isn’t funny: Joking About Animal Ethicists | Twist of Life

  19. Andrew,
    I know you dropped your facebook account for a while- did you reopen it or start a new one? Regardless, it appears we are no longer connected there. I wanted to post this blog entry of yours with a note I have written along similar lines (although not nearly as compelling as this post) and tag you. I’ll just refer people here instead. Bravo on this inspiring post! In solidarity my vegan brother.
    Eriyah

  20. Absolutely one of the most eloquent and accurate characterization of what it means to be vegan. I so love the question “Is what I’m doing positively impacting animals?” That is such a perfect way for all of us to proceed when we deal with resistance. Thank you!

  21. Thank you…it can become overwhelming, considering the suffering, seeing it, feeling it. It helps to feel like I belong to a community of people who understand.

  22. Jennifer says:

    Whenever I feel too small for change, I listen to the Flobots “Rise”. Universal song. Rise together : )

  23. Lizzie Boyd says:

    This was so moving and inspiring and made me cry tears of pride for myself and all other vegans out there. I will turn to this when the barrage of abuse hits again and gain strength in the knowledge Im right.
    Thank you.

  24. Ziggy Pope says:

    Thank you. I needed this today.

  25. Pingback: An Open Letter to Animal Rights Advocates | One woman

  26. Marlene Gregory says:

    Your quote from Nelson Mandela made me weep….because I can feel the immensity and gravity of his words, in this enormous struggle to free the animals of the horror that humans beings have locked them into.

  27. Reblogged this on There's an Elephant in the Room blog and commented:
    ‘Where there are people advocating for animals, there is compassion, hope, an evolved mind, and a conscience at peace. This is who you are, it is who you will always be … ‘

  28. Thanks for putting into words some reasons for an issue that I often ponder – the rage and impatience that so often surrounds vegan advocacy. Reblogged.

  29. Wow!! You are #1 an excellent and caring human being, #2 you write very, very well and finally I am following you because of all of the above. Right now, because of all the inhumane things that I have seen, I am in the process of becoming a vegan and appreciate your inspiring and encouraging words as I’ve met with some resistance! You are offering an invaluable service and I am following you now!

  30. Thank you!! I needed that.

  31. Christina says:

    I definitely needed to hear this. I’ve shared this on my Facebook wall and have asked friends and family to read this if they want to know what’s in my heart. <3

  32. Thank you for the beautiful letter! Since you bring up abolitionist/realist, I’d like to express an observation.
    I am an abolitionist. This works for me and plays to my strengths as a communicator. However, not everyone is suited for it. And not every scenario asks for an abolitionist approach. I feel that if we tried to make everyone abolitionist, we would have a lot of advocates out there poorly representing the movement when they might have made very moving welfarists.
    In the grand scheme of things, shouldn’t we be supporting the efforts of all advocates? As long as our advocacy always ALWAYS ties back to veganism, I can’t see that some single-issue campaigns could undermine the movement. But we *must* always keep veganism as the goal, and to accomplish it as swiftly as possible.
    Thoughts?

  33. Cindy Tozer says:

    Well said.

  34. janice rendle says:

    brilliant! thank you for your words! I’m vegan

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s